After a handful of PPJ shows, audiences have cast over 300 votes for 92 different songs. The top voted songs so far include:
- "Rocket Man"
- "American Pie"
- "Time After Time"
- "Piano Man"
- "Wish You Were Here"
- "Shallow"
- "Creep"
- "Your Song"
- "With or Without You"
- "Stand By Me"
- "Brown Eyed Girl"
- "Is She Really Going Out With Him?"
- "Psycho Killer"
- "Take Me Home, Country Roads"
- "Ain’t Too Proud To Beg"
- "My Way"
- "Desperado"
- "Baby One More Time"
- "You Are So Beautiful"
- "Take Me to the River"
- "I Left My Heart In San Francisco"
- "Hey Jude"
- "Vienna"
- "Levon"
- "Great Balls of Fire"
- "Always On My Mind"
- "You’ll Be Back"
- "Werewolves of London"
- "Angel Eyes"
- "New York State of Mind"
A PPJ show runs the gamut from the oldies in Great Balls of Fire and Stand By Me to more modern hits like Shallow and (Hit Me) Baby, One More Time. Sprinkle in some 1970s and 1980s classics like Piano Man, With or Without You, and Psycho Killer, and everyone is sure to hear something they love and find themselves singing along!